Retirement / 401(k) rollover and IRA
401(k) rollover: go direct to avoid withholding and penalties
After leaving a job you can move an old 401(k) to an IRA or a new employer plan. A direct trustee-to-trustee transfer is safest; a cheque made out to you can trigger 20% withholding and a 60-day deadline.
Three options
Leave it in the old plan, move it to a new employer plan, or roll it to an IRA. Investment choice, fees, and protection differ, so compare before deciding.
| Option | Pro | Con |
|---|---|---|
| Stay | No move | Limited choice |
| New plan | Consolidated | Plan limits |
| IRA | Most choice | Self-managed |
Direct versus indirect
A direct transfer moves assets between institutions without touching you and usually avoids withholding; an indirect transfer pays you, may withhold 20%, and requires you to replace the full amount within 60 days.
| Item | Direct | Indirect |
|---|---|---|
| Cheque | Institution to institution | To you |
| Withholding | Usually none | May be 20% |
| Deadline | More flexible | 60 days |
| Risk | Lower | Higher |
Choosing an IRA
Traditional and Roth IRAs differ in tax timing; a conversion creates taxable income. Confirm whether you are rolling over or converting, because the rules differ.
A rollover is not a conversion.
Calculate the tax cost before converting.
A USD 50,000 example
An old 401(k) holds USD 50,000. An indirect rollover with 20% withholding pays you USD 40,000; you must add USD 10,000 within 60 days or that part may be treated as an early distribution with tax and penalties.
Withholding is not tax, but it creates a cash gap.
A direct transfer avoids the gap.
Fees and investment choice
Compare plan administration fees, fund expenses, and investment menus; low costs matter over decades. An IRA may or may not charge an account fee.
Do not focus only on the one-off transfer fee.
Three common errors
Taking the cheque
Withholding and deadlines.
Missing 60 days
Treated as a distribution.
Confusing rollover and conversion
Wrong tax treatment.
Checklist before rolling over
Confirm the old plan allows a rollover, the new plan accepts it, and compare investment menus and fees. Have ID and account numbers ready, and choose a direct transfer.
Call to confirm the process before submitting forms.
Three common errors
No receipt check
Assets go missing.
Ignoring fees
Higher long-term cost.
Forgetting beneficiaries
Estate planning breaks.
Five common questions
Must a rollover be direct?
It is strongly recommended; indirect transfers carry withholding and deadline risk.
Is a rollover taxable?
A direct rollover usually is not; a conversion can create taxable income.
Can I roll over part of the balance?
Yes, if both plans allow it.
How is the 60-day window counted?
From the day you receive the funds; holidays may extend it under tax rules.
Can non-residents roll over?
Depends on status and plan; confirm tax and account eligibility.
Sources: Fidelity 401(k) rollover and IRA pages, IRS public materials, checked 2026-11. Not tax advice. Independent guide, not affiliated with Fidelity.