Retirement / Accounts
Retirement accounts: three choices, three tax treatments
Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, and 401(k) differ in contributions, withdrawals, and tax. The wrong account can cost a lot over decades.
Three accounts compared
Traditional may be deductible and taxed on withdrawal; Roth is after-tax with qualified tax-free withdrawals; 401(k) is employer-provided.
| Account | Contribution | Withdrawal |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional IRA | May be pre-tax | Usually taxed |
| Roth IRA | After-tax | Qualified tax-free |
| 401(k) | Employer plan | Plan and age rules |
Eligibility and contributions
IRAs need US earned income and tax status; 401(k)s come from employers. Limits depend on the year and age, with catch-up contributions.
| Item | IRA | 401(k) |
|---|---|---|
| Status | US tax resident | Employee |
| Income | Earned income | Employer plan |
| Contribution | Annual limit | Plan limit |
| Catch-up | Age 50+ | Plan-dependent |
Withdrawals and penalties
Early withdrawals usually trigger a 10% penalty and tax; exceptions follow IRS rules. Roth qualified withdrawals are tax-free, but not all withdrawals qualify.
| Case | Traditional | Roth |
|---|---|---|
| Before 59½ | Possible penalty and tax | Contributions may come out; earnings may be penalised |
| After 59½ | Taxed | Qualified tax-free |
| RMD | Yes | Generally no for original owner |
How to choose
High tax now
Traditional may help: deduct now, withdraw at a lower rate.
Low tax now
Roth may help: pay tax now, withdraw tax-free.
Employer match
Capture the full 401(k) match first; it is a certain return.
Contribution limits and catch-up
IRAs and 401(k)s have different annual limits; age 50+ usually allows catch-up. Limits adjust with inflation.
| Account | Annual limit | Catch-up |
|---|---|---|
| IRA | IRS limit | Age 50+ |
| 401(k) | Plan limit | Age 50+ |
| Roth IRA | IRS limit | Age 50+ |
Roth conversions: tax first
Converting a Traditional IRA to Roth adds the amount to current income; a high tax rate may make it unattractive.
Benefits are future tax-free growth and no RMD; the cost is tax now. It suits lower-tax years, cash to pay the tax, and higher expected future rates.
Do not pay the conversion tax from the retirement account; that reduces assets and may trigger penalties.
RMD: you cannot hold forever
Traditional IRAs and 401(k)s require minimum withdrawals after a certain age; missing them can trigger penalties. Roth IRAs generally have no RMD for the original owner.
RMD affects tax and cash flow; calculate it in advance.
Five common questions
Traditional or Roth?
Depends on current versus future tax rates; there is no universal answer.
Can I contribute without earned income?
Usually no; an IRA needs earned income, with possible spousal exceptions.
Should I take the full 401(k) match?
Usually yes; the match is a certain extra return.
Can I have both an IRA and a 401(k)?
Yes, but limits and deductibility depend on income and the plan.
Can non-residents use them?
Usually no; US tax status and earned income are required.
Sources: IRS public guidance and Fidelity.com IRA and 401(k) pages, checked 2026-11. Not tax advice. Independent guide, not affiliated with Fidelity Investments.