Retirement / 401(k) rollovers
401(k) rollovers: go direct, not through your hands
After leaving a job, an old 401(k) can move to a new plan or IRA. Direct rollovers usually avoid withholding; indirect rollovers may withhold 20%, which you must replace in time.
Two rollover methods
Direct moves between institutions and usually avoids withholding; indirect sends a check to you, may withhold 20%, and requires you to replace the full amount within 60 days.
| Method | Process | Tax |
|---|---|---|
| Direct | Institution to institution | Usually no withholding |
| Indirect | Check to you | Possible 20% withholding |
| Leave in plan | No move | Plan-dependent |
Timing and documents
Rollovers can take weeks; confirm the old plan's outbound process, the new account details, and whether notarisation is needed.
| Item | Confirm | Common issue |
|---|---|---|
| Old plan | Allows rollover | In-service restrictions |
| New account | Already open | Missing details |
| Tax | Direct or indirect | 20% withholding |
| Timing | 60-day window | Missed replacement |
Fees and investment choice
Compare the old plan and new account on fees, fund choices, and service; rolling over is not always better.
| Case | Suggestion | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Old plan is cheap | May stay | Rollover may not improve |
| Want more choice | Roll to IRA | Broader investments |
| New plan is good | Roll to new plan | Consolidation |
| Need a loan | Be careful | IRAs do not allow loans |
Three common errors
Taking the check
Possible 20% withholding that you must replace.
Missing 60 days
Late replacement may be treated as a withdrawal.
Ignoring fees
Higher new fees erode returns over time.
Direct rollover: four steps
Open a new IRA or confirm the new plan, request the old plan's outbound form, choose a direct rollover, then track and reconcile.
| Step | Action | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| Open | New IRA or plan | Day 1 |
| Request | Old plan form | Days |
| Transfer | Institution to institution | Weeks |
| Reconcile | Confirm amount and investments | After arrival |
The cost of a Roth conversion
Moving a Traditional 401(k) to a Roth IRA is a taxable conversion; the amount counts as income. Without cash to pay the tax, it may not be worthwhile.
Calculate the tax and confirm the cash source before converting; do not chase "tax-free" and ignore today's bill.
Lower income and higher future rates may favour conversion; the opposite may not.
Post-transfer checks
Confirm amount, allocation, cost basis, and beneficiaries; contact both institutions immediately if anything is missing.
Keep transfer documents and statements; you may need them at tax time.
Five common questions
Is a direct rollover taxable?
Usually not, but rules depend on the plan and tax law; check IRS and broker documents.
Can I recover the 20% withheld?
If you replace the full amount within 60 days, you may avoid tax; otherwise it may be a withdrawal.
Must I roll over?
No; if the old plan is cheap and has enough choice, staying can be reasonable.
How long does it take?
Weeks, depending on the old plan and new account.
Can I roll to a Roth IRA?
Yes, but it may be a taxable conversion; calculate the tax first.
Sources: IRS public guidance and Fidelity.com 401(k) rollover pages, checked 2026-11. Not tax advice. Independent guide, not affiliated with Fidelity Investments.